Food & Beverage

Cicis Pizza, Nutter Butter team up on fudge brownie dessert

Image: Cicis Pizza

August 25, 2026

Summarize with

Cicis Pizza has introduced a limited-time Fudge Brownie made with Nutter Butter cookies, according to a press release.

The dessert, created in collaboration with the cookie brand, features the chain's traditional fudge brownie with Nutter Butter Minis baked into the batter. It is finished with a creamy peanut butter icing, creating a sweet-and-salty chocolate and peanut butter combination.

The dessert is included in the restaurant's $9.99 all-you-can-eat buffet, which also features a variety of pizzas, pasta and salad.

"Cicis fans do not play around when it comes to our brownies, so we knew we had to make this one count," Jeff Hetsel, president of Cicis Pizza, said in the release. "We took a dessert people already love, added Nutter Butter Minis and made it even more indulgent. It is rich, peanut buttery and just a little nuttier, which is exactly what dessert on the Cicis buffet should be."

The collaboration brings a nostalgic twist to one of the buffet's most popular items.

"Nutter Butter has always been about going all in on peanut butter, and teaming up with Cicis gave us the perfect excuse to take that obsession to the buffet," Caroline Suppiger, Nutter Butter brand manager, said in the release. "Cicis brownies already have a loyal following, so adding Nutter Butter Minis and peanut butter icing felt like a deliciously over-the-top way to make a fan favorite even nuttier."

Cicis Pizza has nearly 300 restaurants across more than 22 states