The family of the man who originally bought Schnatter's car believes they are entitled to the reward.

September 1, 2009
Papa John's vice president of corporate communications said the Slones don't qualify for the reward because the contest rules clearly state the winner had to transfer the title to the company."They sold the car nine years before the contest came out, so there was no way they could qualify to be the winner," said Chris Sternberg.Sternberg said the company has offered to pay the Slones $25,000 for helping locate the car, but the familysaid it would sue Papa John's if the company doesn't give her family the $250,000 prize money.